|
Theological Themes
- earthly kingship was seen as a
rejection of divine rule
- the desire to be like other nations
was seen as a rejection of God’s intent for
Israel
to be set apart from other communities
-
Israel’s
desire to emulate other nations permeated the
whole of the nation - their life would be
patterned after secular nations rather than
after the ways decreed by God
- covenant faith was at stake
Political:
-The weaknesses of Israel’s tribal
makeup created the pressure to centralize their
government through a monarchy
-the traditional patterns of
leadership via priestly houses like that of Eli
or spiritual houses like that of Samuel had
failed; Eli’s sons and Samuel’s sons were
corrupt (8:1-13)
- there were conflicts between
Samuel’s “holy war” traditions and more secular
models of military conduct (Saul)
- the increasing population and
economic power of the new nation led to impulses
to create a strong centralized government in
order to protect the emerging interests
Things to Keep in Mind:
Biblical story tellers are not
objective historians. (There is considerable
question whether or not any historian can truly
be objective - all retelling is colored by
interpretation!) The original narrators have
perspectives on the story, and those
perspectives are offered as a teaching device
for current and future generations. These
stories were edited into their final form to fit
the lessons needed by the exiles in Babylon.
Early on, theologians may have been more
positive about the blessings of a centralized
government; later they may have grown negative.
Consider the development of our own nation prior
to the Constitution. Our fore bearers debated
the pros and cons of a strong central
government. Both the Federalist and Republican
sides had the good of the nation at heart. Which
side was God on? This was the debate raging in
Israel.
See: Summary |